If you're a true crime fanatic, you know there's nothing quite like a gripping story rooted in real events. The best true crime podcasts don't just retell cases; they immerse you in mysteries, cold cases, wrongful convictions, and criminal psychology with captivating narration and deep investigation. As 2025 heats up, this guide highlights standout crime podcasts based on real stories—perfect for your next binge.

What makes these shows the best true crime podcasts isn't just shocking details. It's the journalistic care, empathetic storytelling, and relentless pursuit of truth that draw listeners into these real-life tales of tragedy, mystery, and sometimes, justice. Whether you’re new to the genre or searching for fresh true crime podcast recommendations, this list has something unforgettable for every armchair detective.

1. Serial

It’s impossible to talk about the best true crime podcasts without starting with Serial. This groundbreaking series redefined podcasting in 2014 with its detailed investigation of Adnan Syed’s conviction. Host Sarah Koenig’s storytelling balances empathy and critical analysis, making listeners question everything they think they know about justice.

Even years later, Serial remains one of the top crime podcasts based on real stories for those seeking thoughtful, layered reporting. Whether you're just discovering true crime or revisiting the classics, this remains essential listening among the best true crime podcasts of all time.

2. Someone Knows Something

David Ridgen’s Someone Knows Something is a masterclass in investigative storytelling. Each season focuses on a different cold case, with Ridgen forming close relationships with victims' families as he methodically reexamines evidence. It's personal, heartbreaking, and frequently yields new leads.

Among true crime podcast recommendations, Someone Knows Something stands out for its emotional depth. Ridgen’s respectful approach reminds listeners that behind every case are real families seeking closure, making this series one of the best true crime podcasts for listeners who value humanity as much as mystery.

3. My Favorite Murder

Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark bring humor and heart to horrifying tales with My Favorite Murder. This beloved show blends candid storytelling, comedy, and advocacy, making it one of the most accessible—and addictive—true crime podcast and murder mystery podcast recommendations.

Their witty banter has created an enormous community of “Murderinos” worldwide. If you're looking for the best true crime podcasts that feel like listening to your funniest friends discuss terrifying topics, My Favorite Murder should be at the top of your list.

4. Criminal

If you prefer beautifully produced, story-driven narratives, Criminal—hosted by Phoebe Judge—is a must. Rather than focusing solely on brutal crimes, Criminal explores all aspects of criminal behavior, from infamous heists to unusual scams.

This rich, literary approach makes it one of the best true crime podcasts for listeners interested in the broader human condition behind crime. Every episode feels intimate and profound, proving that not all crime podcasts based on real stories need to shock to captivate.

5. Sword and Scale

For listeners craving darker, rawer content, Sword and Scale digs deep into the psychology of criminals. Covering everything from horrifying murder cases to chilling 911 calls, this show doesn't shy away from the grisly realities of crime.

Although it’s more graphic than many best true crime podcasts, Sword and Scale offers a deeply immersive experience. It's one of the top best serial killer podcasts for those who want unfiltered true crime that goes beyond surface details.

6. Crime Junkie

Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat deliver concise, suspenseful episodes every week in Crime Junkie, one of the most binge-worthy best true crime podcasts available. Their format—quick, detailed retellings with just the right amount of commentary—makes it easy to devour multiple episodes at once.

For anyone searching for true crime podcast recommendations that offer polished storytelling without excessive filler, Crime Junkie is a top contender. Its accessible style has made it a favorite among most listened to podcasts in the U.S.

7. Morbid

Combining macabre humor with deep research, Morbid—hosted by autopsy technician Alaina Urquhart and hairstylist Ash Kelley—is a delightful addition to the world of true crime podcast recommendations. Their dynamic creates a fun yet respectful atmosphere, balancing gruesome details with levity.

Among the best true crime podcasts, Morbid stands out for its energy and emotional intelligence. It’s perfect for listeners who want smart commentary mixed with genuine enthusiasm for the genre.

8. Up and Vanished

This serialized podcast investigates real missing person cases, beginning with the 2005 disappearance of Georgia teacher Tara Grinstead. Host Payne Lindsey’s dogged reporting actually helped reignite public interest—and eventually led to major case developments.

Up and Vanished combines amateur enthusiasm with real investigative impact, making it one of the most exciting best true crime podcasts for listeners who love the idea of helping uncover the truth.

9. The Dropout

While not about murder, The Dropout—chronicling Elizabeth Holmes and the Theranos scandal—is an incredible exploration of crime, ambition, and deception. ABC News reporter Rebecca Jarvis narrates the rise and fall of the biotech fraudster in riveting detail.

If you're branching into true crime podcast recommendations beyond homicides, The Dropout is one of the best crime podcasts based on real stories—showing how corporate greed can be just as chilling as violence.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the #1 rated true crime podcast?

Serial remains widely regarded as the top-rated true crime podcast, credited with sparking the modern podcast boom and setting a gold standard for investigative storytelling.

Where can I listen to true crime podcasts?

You can find the best true crime podcasts on platforms like Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, Audible, and Stitcher—all offering vast true crime libraries for free or with premium upgrades.

What are the best true crime podcasts for beginners?

Start with Crime Junkie, My Favorite Murder, or Criminal. These shows offer compelling stories and accessible styles that are great for new true crime fans.

Are there true crime podcasts based on real unsolved mysteries?

Yes—shows like Someone Knows Something and Up and Vanished dive into unsolved cases and often help reignite investigations, making them favorites among true crime enthusiasts.

What are the best serial killer podcasts?

For serial killer-focused stories, check out Sword and Scale, The Clearing, and classic Serial for detailed, often chilling investigations into infamous and lesser-known cases.

Why These True Crime Podcasts Stand Out

The best true crime podcasts offer more than sensational headlines—they offer empathy, curiosity, and a deep desire to understand human behavior and justice. Whether you love tightly edited mystery series, quirky conversational styles, or psychological deep dives, today's true crime podcast recommendations have never been more diverse or compelling.

In 2025, the appetite for crime podcasts based on real stories continues to grow, with listeners seeking shows that not only inform but also leave a lasting impact. From intimate family dramas to major criminal scandals, the world of best true crime podcasts offers a chilling, fascinating window into our darkest mysteries—and our endless search for truth.